This is a research paper The paper is a qualitative research paper. I want a critique of the article  attached below and here is the instruction and requirement of the paper
B.    Critique
Identification of report elements. Evaluate objectively, then explain how these elements from the chosen study meet (or do not meet) the expected definition and purpose of each element
1.    Descriptive Vividness
2.    Documentation of Participants
3.    Methodological Congruence
4.    Ethical Standards
5.    Auditability

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S8755722319300870?via=ihub